Kenya, a nation celebrated for its resilience and potential, continues to grapple with deep-rooted governance and leadership challenges. From the erosion of trust in public institutions to endemic corruption, the country’s political and economic systems are plagued by inefficiencies that hinder progress. In a recent interview with Professor PLO Lumumba, a renowned legal scholar and advocate, critical insights into Kenya’s governance problems were discussed. This article explores these issues, offering an analysis of the systemic challenges facing the nation and potential pathways to reform.
-
Leadership
PLO Lumumba says one of the most glaring issues in Kenya’s leadership is the “Messiah Syndrome,” where political leaders position themselves as saviours of the nation. Professor PLO Lumumba aptly described this as a misguided belief that leaders are divinely sent to solve all problems. This mentality fosters a culture of dependency and stifles the development of collective responsibility among citizens.
Additionally, Kenya’s leadership suffers from short-termism, where leaders prioritise immediate political gains over long-term national development. Lumumba highlighted the stark contrast between the visionary leadership of Kenya’s early post-independence years and the current crop of politicians, who often focus on personal enrichment and ethnic loyalty. This shift has led to a lack of strategic planning and a failure to address critical issues such as education, healthcare, and infrastructure development.
-
Corruption
Corruption remains one of Kenya’s most significant governance challenges. Despite the existence of institutions like the Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (EACC), the fight against corruption has been largely ineffective. Lumumba noted that corruption is deeply entrenched in Kenyan society, with public office often viewed as a shortcut to wealth accumulation.
The judiciary, which should serve as a bulwark against corruption, has also been implicated in scandals. Lumumba described the judiciary’s current state as “pathetic,” citing instances where justice is allegedly sold to the highest bidder. This erosion of trust in the judiciary undermines the rule of law and perpetuates a culture of impunity.
-
Devolution
Devolution, introduced under Kenya’s 2010 Constitution, was intended to bring governance closer to the people and promote equitable development. However, Lumumba argued that devolution has not lived up to its promise. Many counties are technically insolvent, relying heavily on national government allocations while failing to generate sufficient local revenue.
Moreover, devolution has exacerbated ethnic divisions, with counties often becoming fiefdoms for ethnic groups and clans. This ethnicization of governance undermines national unity and creates barriers to inclusive development. Lumumba suggested that merging counties and rethinking the devolution model could address these issues, but political resistance remains a significant obstacle.
-
Constitution Adherence
Kenya’s 2010 Constitution marked a significant milestone in the country’s governance journey, introducing progressive provisions such as devolution, human rights protections, and gender equality. However, PLO Lumumba lamented that many of these provisions have not been fully implemented. For instance, Chapter Six of the Constitution, which outlines leadership and integrity standards, has been largely ignored.
Attempts to amend the Constitution, such as the Building Bridges Initiative (BBI) and the National Dialogue Conference (NADCO), have also raised concerns. Lumumba argued that these initiatives are often driven by political expediency rather than genuine efforts to improve governance. He warned against constitutional amendments that seek to entrench mechanisms like the National Government Constituencies Development Fund (NGCDF), which he described as a “slash fund” for influence peddling.
-
Political Cultism
Kenya’s political landscape is dominated by ethnic kingpins and personal cults, which stifle the development of issue-based politics. PLO Lumumba referred to these leaders as “low voltage warlords,” who exploit ethnic divisions to maintain their grip on power. This focus on ethnicity over ideology has led to the proliferation of political parties that serve as vehicles for personal ambition rather than platforms for national development.
The lack of trust in the political class is evident in the public’s reaction to their actions. Lumumba noted that many Kenyans celebrate when politicians face tragedy, reflecting the deep resentment and disillusionment with the political elite. This erosion of empathy is a symptom of the broader societal malaise caused by decades of poor governance.
-
Economic Challenges: A Toxic Environment for Growth
Kenya’s economy is burdened by a combination of factors, including punitive taxation, high electricity costs, and widespread corruption. Lumumba described the country’s economic policies as unfriendly to investors, leading to capital flight to neighboring countries like Rwanda and Tanzania.
The government’s borrowing practices have also come under scrutiny, with concerns about the sustainability of Kenya’s debt portfolio. PLO Lumumba argued that public funds are often misused, with little accountability for how they are spent. This culture of consumption without production has created an economic environment that stifles growth and innovation.
-
Economic Participation – The potential according to PLO Lumumba
Despite the challenges, Lumumba expressed guarded optimism about Kenya’s future. He emphasized the importance of citizen engagement in holding leaders accountable and pushing for change. The Gen Z-led protests against the Finance Bill in 2023 were a testament to the power of collective action. Lumumba urged young people to organize themselves and participate in the electoral process, noting that the ballot could shock the nation if used effectively.
He also called on the media to focus on issues that unite Kenyans, such as agriculture, education, and innovation, rather than amplifying divisive rhetoric from politicians. By fostering a culture of accountability and promoting issue-based discourse, citizens can play a crucial role in shaping Kenya’s governance trajectory.
Kenya’s governance and leadership challenges are complex and multifaceted, but they are not insurmountable. The country has made significant strides in areas such as human rights and political space, but much work remains to be done.
As PLO Lumumba noted, the journey to a prosperous Kenya requires a collective effort from citizens, leaders, and institutions. By addressing corruption, rethinking devolution, and promoting issue-based politics, Kenya can build a governance system that serves the interests of all its people. The road ahead may be long and arduous, but with sustained commitment and vigilance, the dream of a united, prosperous Kenya can become a reality.
The challenges Kenya faces are daunting, but the opportunities for change are immense.
ALSO READ: Janet Mbugua On Gender Equality And Fixing Today’s Society
